Learning From Others Without Copying Them

There is a version of learning from others that makes you worse. You find someone further along, adopt their systems wholesale, and end up running a business that fits their circumstances and not yours.

The useful version looks different. It borrows the reasoning rather than the conclusion, which is slower, less satisfying to post about, and considerably more likely to work in a business that is not theirs.

Why Copying the Tactic Fails

Every visible decision sits on top of invisible conditions. The pricing model that works for them assumes a client base you do not have. The hiring decision assumes cash flow you cannot match. The marketing channel assumes an audience built over six years that nobody mentions in the case study.

You see the tactic. You do not see the conditions. So the tactic gets transplanted into different soil and produces a different result, and the natural conclusion is that you executed badly rather than that the tactic was never portable.

Learning from others properly means reconstructing the reasoning: what problem were they solving, what were the constraints, what did they give up to do it. Once you have that, you can ask whether the same reasoning points anywhere useful in your situation, which is frequently somewhere completely different.

Choosing Who to Learn From

Most people choose badly here, aiming at whoever is most visible rather than whoever is most relevant.

• One step ahead, not ten. Someone who solved your problem last year remembers the details. Someone who solved it a decade ago remembers a story about it.
• People who did the thing, not people who teach the thing. Both can be valuable, but they are different sources and should be weighted differently.
• People whose constraints resemble yours. Similar size, similar market, similar amount of outside money. Constraints shape decisions more than talent does.
• People who will tell you what went wrong. Anyone whose account of their own progress contains no serious mistakes is giving you a marketing narrative, not information.

The most useful sources are usually unremarkable to look at: the owner two years ahead of you in an adjacent trade, who is not building an audience and will happily explain what they got wrong. That is also the case for what a mentor actually does, when the relationship is a real one.

The Questions That Get Real Answers

“How did you grow?” produces a rehearsed answer. Better questions are narrower and slightly awkward.

What would you not do again? What did that cost you that you did not expect? What were you doing in the six months before it worked? Who did you have to disappoint? What advice did you take that turned out to be wrong for you?

Those questions get past the tidy version, because the tidy version has no answers for them. They also tend to produce the specific, unglamorous detail that actually transfers: the sequencing, the thing they fixed first, the eighteen months of nothing that preceded the visible result.

And when someone cannot answer them at all, that is information too. It usually means the outcome had more to do with circumstances than method, which is worth knowing before you build a plan on it.

Testing a Borrowed Idea Properly

The failure mode after a good conversation is adopting four things at once, so that when something shifts you have no idea which one caused it, and when nothing shifts you conclude all four were useless.

Take one idea. Decide in advance what you expect to happen and roughly when. Give it long enough to be a fair test, which for most marketing and pricing changes means a quarter rather than a fortnight. Then look honestly at whether it did what you expected.

Keep a short record of what you have borrowed and how it went. Over a couple of years that record teaches you something no individual source can: which kinds of advice tend to work in your specific business, and which kinds never do. That is the point at which learning from others stops being a series of experiments and starts being judgement.

The Takeaway

Learning from others is a skill in itself, and most people are doing the imitation version without realising there is another one available.

Pick one person a step or two ahead whose constraints resemble yours. Ask what they would not do again and what it cost them. Take one idea, decide what you expect from it, and give it a fair run before judging. Write down what you borrowed and what happened.

If you want that as a structured relationship rather than an occasional conversation, that is what my one-to-one work is. Gov.uk’s business support pages list the free routes if you would rather start there.

Ayse Durmush

AI Visibility Expert & Global Business Consultant

Ayse has spent three decades transforming strategy, lead generation and operations for businesses of every size, and has consulted for high profile global brands. She writes about AI visibility, mindset and building a business that can survive its founder.

More about AyseWork with Ayse one to oneAll articles

Keep reading

Personal GrowthThe Habits of Self-Made Millionaires, Minus the MythologyPersonal GrowthLessons From Athletes: Why Recovery Is Part of the WorkPersonal GrowthWhat a Business Mentor Actually Does, and When You Need One